I would consider getting the lower powered of the two, or a used 250cc Kawasaki Ninja- more reliable, easier to get parts for, lighter, and good power to learn with. A bike more than 10 years old with low miles might have mechanical problems from years of sitting, and it will likely be difficult to buy parts for it.
A 60cc to 400cc scooter is a very safe first street bike- no clutch or shift lever so you can focus more on steering and braking, then move up later to a manual shifter. The weak handling and braking and power are good learning tools and will prevent speeding tickets.
I rode and crashed an automatic transmission 3.5 horsepower minibike when I was 8 years old. Then I went to a 30mph top speed, to 60 mph, to 105 mph, down to 95 mph, then 155 mph.
“…[Most] try to wring from the unknown the answers they have already shaped in their own minds...It has taken eighteen hundred years to come back to the skepticism, the level of practicality that was our daily frame of mind then..." From the 1985 The Vampire Lestat novel by Anne Rice