Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Colorado Springs, CO
Apologies, been a stressful day for me (came online to relieve stress from preparing for Grandpa's funeral tomorrow).
Double check that when you have the bike off, you roll the bike back and forth as you try to shift it. Does the lever go back to the center when you're trying to shift it? If not, I'd put money on it being a broken spring on the ratchet in there.